Comparison · 2026
Income Refinery vs the alternatives
A side-by-side comparison of the nine major dividend trackers and passive income tools — Sharesight, Snowball Analytics, TrackYourDividends, DivTracker, Stock Events, Empower (Personal Capital), Simply Safe Dividends, Portfolio Visualizer, and the humble spreadsheet, so you can choose the right tool for how you actually invest.
The short version
Pick the tool that matches how you invest, not the one with the loudest marketing.
Quick answer: Income Refinery is a free, browser-based passive income and dividend tracker that requires no account and stores no data in the cloud. Pro is a one-time $49 for unlimited tracking: the only major dividend tracker without a recurring subscription. It is the right pick for income investors who want privacy, multi-stream tracking (dividends + rent + bonds + savings), and ownership of their tool. Choose Sharesight ($7–23/mo) for tax reports and auto broker sync; Snowball Analytics (from ~$80/yr) for backtesting; Portfolio Visualizer for allocation modelling (not income tracking).
If you want automatic broker sync and detailed tax reports, Sharesight or Snowball Analytics will serve you best, but accept that you're handing over your portfolio data and paying a recurring subscription in return.
If you want portfolio backtesting and asset-allocation modelling, Portfolio Visualizer is purpose-built for that. It is not a real-time income tracker.
If you want a private, account-free passive income dashboard that consolidates dividends, rental income, bonds, savings interest and every other passive stream, converted to your home currency, laid out month by month, with a one-time payment instead of a subscription — Income Refinery is the only major tool built specifically for that.
If you keep a dividend tracker spreadsheet, Income Refinery is essentially that spreadsheet, automated. Same privacy, none of the maintenance.
At a glance
How each option actually compares
Pricing and plan limits below were checked against each vendor's public pages in October 2026. Prices and limits change; if anything here is out of date, please email hello@incomerefinery.com and it will be corrected.
| Feature | Income Refinery Pro | Sharesight | Snowball Analytics | TrackYourDividends | DivTracker | Stock Events | Empower (Personal Capital) | Simply Safe Dividends | Portfolio Visualizer | Spreadsheet |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | $49 one-time | $7–$23/mo subscription | ~$80–$250/yr subscription | $9.99/mo or $99.99/yr | $19.99–$49.99/yr | $49.99/yr (Pro) | Free (AUM upsell) | $468/yr subscription | Annual subscription | Free |
| Account required | ✓ No account | Email + password | Email + password | Email + password | Account (optional on iOS) | Email + password | Email + phone | Email + password | None on Free; login for paid | ✓ No account |
| Data stored | Your browser only | Vendor cloud | Vendor cloud | Vendor cloud | Local, then vendor cloud after sign-up | Vendor cloud | Vendor cloud + Yodlee | Vendor cloud | Vendor cloud | Your device |
| Free tier limit | 10 + 1 + 3 streams | 10 holdings, 1 portfolio | 10 holdings, 1 portfolio | 1 Plaid acct + manual | 1 portfolio, 5 holdings | 15 stocks, no ads | Free | 14-day trial | 15-asset model | Unlimited |
| Tracks dividends | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Basic | ✓ | Backtest only | ✓ Manual |
| Tracks rental income | ✓ First-class | Custom investment | Custom asset | No | No | Custom asset (1 free) | Net worth only | No | No | ✓ Manual |
| Tracks bonds, savings, royalties, pension | ✓ 12 categories | Bonds, cash, custom | Custom assets | No | No | Custom assets | Net worth only | Bonds & CDs | No | ✓ Manual |
| 12-month income calendar | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | No | ✓ | No | DIY |
| Multi-currency w/ live FX | ✓ Live rates | Paid plans | ✓ 30+ currencies | Limited | Limited | ✓ | USD-focused | USD-focused | USD-focused | DIY |
| Broker auto-sync | Manual / CSV | ✓ | ✓ 1,000+ | ✓ Plaid | ✓ | ✓ US only | ✓ Yodlee | Some | No | No |
| Tax reports | No | ✓ Strong | Some | Some | No | No | Some | No | No | DIY |
| Excel / JSON export | ✓ Multi-sheet Excel | ✓ Excel/PDF | ✓ CSV | Limited | Limited | Pro: Excel add-in | Some | Table export | ✓ | ✓ |
| FI Milestones (Lean / Standard / Fat / Coast FI) | ✓ Built-in | No | Net worth & income goals | No | No | Income goal only | Retirement only | No | No | DIY |
| Forecast & What-If Scenario Modeller | ✓ Built-in | Dividend forecast | Projections only | Future value projections | Income forecast | Future values (25 yrs) | Retirement | Income forecast | ✓ Strong | DIY |
| Works offline after first load | ✓ | No | No | No | iOS app only | No | No | No | No | ✓ |
Sources: each vendor's public pricing page, checked October 2026. ✓ = supported, partial / italic = supported with caveats, ✗ = not supported.
1 · The DIY route
Income Refinery vs Spreadsheets
Most income investors start with a dividend tracker spreadsheet, usually a downloaded template from a finance blog, then customised over months until it sprawls into something only its creator understands. Spreadsheets and Income Refinery share the most important property: your saved portfolio stays on your own device. The difference is how much work you do to get a usable monthly income view.
Income Refinery
- Pre-built 12-month income calendar; no formulas to maintain
- Live FX rates (ECB-based, with a backup source) auto-fetched and cached; no manual updates
- 8-source dividend lookup pipeline auto-fills the latest DPU and, where the payment history confirms it, the payment months
- Native handling for stocks, REITs, ETFs, rent, bonds, HYSA, royalties, pension
- Multi-currency conversion to your chosen base currency
- Withholding tax toggle, blended yields, dividend health signals (Pro)
- Less freeform than a blank spreadsheet: structured fields, not arbitrary columns
Spreadsheets
- Completely free
- Same privacy posture: your saved portfolio stays on your own device
- Infinite flexibility: model anything you can write a formula for
- You build and maintain everything: layout, formulas, FX conversion, payment schedules
- FX rates go stale unless you wire up GOOGLEFINANCE or an external API
- One broken cell reference can silently corrupt your monthly totals
- No built-in dividend lookup; you copy DPU manually from each source
Choose Income Refinery if
You want everything a passive income spreadsheet does, without the maintenance. You hold income sources across multiple currencies. You want a 12-month calendar, FI progress bar and yield tracking out of the box. You'd rather spend evenings reviewing your portfolio than debugging cell references.
Stay with a spreadsheet if
You enjoy spreadsheet-building as a hobby, your tracking needs are highly idiosyncratic (e.g. custom tax-lot rules, options strategies, complex covered-call accounting), or your portfolio is so simple that a 10-row sheet covers it.
3 · The dividend analytics specialist
Income Refinery vs Snowball Analytics
Snowball Analytics is the most dividend-focused SaaS tracker. It offers automated broker sync via Yodlee/SnapTrade, a dividend calendar, payout-quality signals, backtesting, and a public-portfolio community. It is the closest functional overlap with Income Refinery in terms of "dividend-first thinking," but the two products take very different positions on cost, privacy and scope.
Income Refinery Pro
- $49 once vs Snowball's $80+ every single year, indefinitely
- Runs in your browser; no Yodlee aggregator credentials shared
- Same dividend calendar, yield-on-cost, blended portfolio yield
- Rental property + bonds + savings + 9 other categories as first-class income types
- Forecast & What-If Scenario Modeller: test lump-sum capital deployment, changes to holding distributions and hypothetical holdings, properties or other income streams
- No backtesting (use Portfolio Visualizer for that, see below)
- No public-portfolio community / social sharing
- No automatic broker sync
Snowball Analytics
- Automated broker sync via Yodlee + SnapTrade (1,000+ brokers)
- Backtesting with up to 30+ years of historical data (Investor and Expert plans)
- Public portfolio sharing and community features
- Dividend rating system with payout-cut risk signals
- One-click rebalancing recommendations
- Recurring annual subscription; free tier capped at 10 holdings, 1 portfolio
- Stock and ETF prices are delayed; not for active trading
- Real estate is a manual "custom asset" only, not a first-class income type
Choose Income Refinery if
You want Snowball's dividend-first analytics (calendar, yield, projections) without the annual subscription or the cloud account. You track meaningful passive income from outside the stock market (rent, bonds, savings). You'd rather own your tool than rent it.
Choose Snowball Analytics if
Automated broker sync across many accounts is a hard requirement. You want serious backtesting and rebalancing recommendations. You enjoy seeing how your portfolio compares to other investors in a community.
4 · The freemium US-focused tracker
Income Refinery vs TrackYourDividends
TrackYourDividends (TYD) is a US-focused dividend tracker with Plaid brokerage sync, a dividend calendar, and a proprietary safety score. The free tier lets you sync one brokerage and manually add unlimited holdings; the paid tier adds unlimited linked accounts, safety scores, a screener and a watchlist. It's a solid choice for US dividend investors who only hold stocks, but Income Refinery is a better fit if your income mix is broader or you invest globally.
Income Refinery Pro
- 30 global exchanges: NYSE, NASDAQ, LSE, ASX, TSX, HKEX, SGX, plus 23 more
- Multi-currency with live FX rates
- Tracks rent, bonds, HYSA, royalties, all in the same dashboard as dividends
- $49 one-time vs $99.99/year ongoing
- No Plaid; no aggregator with read access to your accounts
- Dividend Health Panel with DPU trend signals: flags changes in the payment data you enter, not a black-box score
- No Plaid sync (this matters if you have many US accounts)
TrackYourDividends
- Free Plaid sync of one brokerage account
- TYD Safety Score for predicting dividend cuts
- Future value projections (free plan)
- Clean, easy-to-learn interface
- Strong US bias: international coverage is limited
- Investments only; no rental income, no bond/savings tracking
- Plaid connection gives a third party read access to your brokerage
Choose Income Refinery if
You invest internationally, hold income outside US stocks (rent, bonds, savings), or simply don't want a Plaid connection to your brokerage. You prefer one-time pricing.
Choose TrackYourDividends if
You're a US investor with one or two US brokerages, you hold mainly US stocks, and Plaid sync is genuinely valuable to you. The TYD Safety Score is useful if you screen for cut risk.
5 · The aggregated net worth dashboard
Income Refinery vs Empower (Personal Capital)
Empower (formerly Personal Capital) is a free net-worth aggregator that links to your banks and brokerages through a third-party aggregator (Yodlee). It is funded by upselling users to its wealth-management service. When you sign up, expect calls from an advisor. It is a net worth dashboard, not a passive income tracker. The two tools answer different questions: Empower tells you "what am I worth"; Income Refinery tells you "what is my portfolio paying me each month."
Income Refinery Pro
- Built specifically for income tracking: calendar, target, monthly cadence
- No account aggregator, no advisor calls, ever
- No KYC, no email collected, no marketing follow-up
- Multi-currency with global exchange coverage
- Tracks every income type Empower lumps under "investments" or "other"
- Doesn't show net worth, spending, or debt
- No automatic account sync
Empower (Personal Capital)
- Genuinely free net worth and spending dashboard
- Aggregates banks, brokerages, mortgages, credit cards
- Retirement and fee analysis
- Useful S&P 500 benchmark comparisons
- Advisors will contact you: that's the business model
- Income tracking is basic; no 12-month calendar, no target tracker
- Empower and its aggregator (Yodlee) hold access to most of your financial life
- USD-focused; weak for non-US investors
Choose Income Refinery if
You specifically want to know your monthly passive income, not your net worth. You don't want an advisor's number. You'd rather not give an aggregator credentials to every account you own.
Use Empower alongside if
You want a free overall financial dashboard and you're comfortable being on an advisor's call list. Many investors use Empower for net worth and a dedicated tool like Income Refinery for income tracking.
6 · The mobile-first apps
Income Refinery vs DivTracker & Stock Events
DivTracker (iOS) and Stock Events (iOS, Android and web) are mobile-first dividend trackers built around the "check your portfolio on your phone in line at the coffee shop" use case. They're well-designed, popular, and reasonably priced. Income Refinery is a browser-based dashboard. It works on phones, but it's optimised for desktop and for being your browser homepage.
Income Refinery Pro
- One-time $49 vs $20–$100 every single year
- No App Store account, no in-app subscription, no platform lock-in
- Set as browser homepage: see your number every time you open a tab
- Tracks income types these apps don't (rent, bonds, savings, royalties)
- Excel multi-sheet export and JSON backup
- No push notifications for ex-dividend dates
- No native iOS/Android app (mobile web works, but it's not an app)
DivTracker / Stock Events
- Native apps with push notifications for dividend events
- Lock-screen widgets (Stock Events especially)
- US brokerage import on DivTracker
- Stock Events tracks crypto and commodities alongside stocks
- Recurring subscription; free tiers are limited (DivTracker: 5 holdings, Stock Events: 15 stocks)
- Built around investments; rent, bonds or savings only as manually valued custom items (Stock Events)
- Account and vendor cloud after sign-up
Choose Income Refinery if
You spend most of your investing time at a desktop or laptop. You want a dashboard you can set as your browser homepage. You want to consolidate dividends with rental income and other passive streams. You prefer one-time pricing.
Choose a mobile app if
Your investing rhythm is "open phone, check portfolio" rather than "sit down at desk." Push notifications for ex-dividend dates and lock-screen widgets genuinely matter to your workflow.
7 · The dividend research platform
Income Refinery vs Simply Safe Dividends
Simply Safe Dividends is a premium dividend research platform best known for its proprietary "Dividend Safety Score," a quantitative model that predicts dividend cuts. It includes a full portfolio tracker, but the main draw is the research and screening. It's a complementary tool to a tracker like Income Refinery, not a direct replacement.
Income Refinery Pro
- $49 one-time vs $468 every year
- Built specifically as a dashboard you check daily
- Dividend Health Panel shows DPU trends with potential cut and growth indicators (Pro)
- Multi-stream: passive income beyond dividends
- No proprietary Safety Score; no analyst research; no stock screener
Simply Safe Dividends
- Dividend Safety Score with strong empirical track record
- Deep research notes and analyst commentary on dividend stocks
- Strong dividend stock screener
- $468/year subscription is one of the most expensive in the space
- Research and screening are the main draw; tracking is one half of the product
- US-focused
Choose Income Refinery if
Your primary need is tracking the income your portfolio generates each month, not researching new dividend picks.
Use Simply Safe Dividends if
You're actively picking individual dividend stocks and the Safety Score plus deep research is worth $468/year to you. Many investors pair the two: Simply Safe for research, a dedicated tracker for ongoing monitoring.
8 · The backtesting tool
Income Refinery vs Portfolio Visualizer
Portfolio Visualizer comes up in the same searches as dividend trackers, but it's a fundamentally different tool. It is a portfolio backtesting and asset-allocation analysis platform: Monte Carlo simulations, tactical allocation models, factor regressions, efficient frontiers. It does not track your current portfolio's ongoing income. It does not have a dividend calendar or rental income tracking. The two tools live happily side-by-side: Portfolio Visualizer to design an allocation, Income Refinery to track the income that allocation actually produces.
Income Refinery Pro
- Real-time tracking of what your portfolio is paying you this month
- 12-month income calendar, blended yields, FI Milestones (Lean / Standard / Fat / Coast FI)
- Multi-stream: dividends + rent + bonds + savings + 9 other categories
- Forecast & What-If Scenario Modeller: projects forward income from lump-sum capital deployment, changes to holding distributions, and hypothetical holdings, properties or other income streams (not historical backtesting)
- One-time $49
- No historical backtesting, Monte Carlo simulations, or efficient frontier analysis
- Not the right tool for "what if I had held this allocation since 1972"
Portfolio Visualizer
- Industry-standard backtesting across asset classes since 1972
- Monte Carlo simulation for portfolio survival modelling
- Factor regression, correlation matrices, efficient frontier optimisation
- Tactical allocation models (momentum, moving averages, volatility targeting)
- Not a portfolio tracker: does not record what you actually own
- No dividend calendar, no rental income, no monthly income view
- US-focused; uses monthly data and total-return assumptions
- Free tier capped at 15 assets per model
Choose Income Refinery if
You want to track what your portfolio is paying you right now, month by month, with a target you're working toward.
Use Portfolio Visualizer if
You're designing an allocation: testing how a mix of asset classes would have performed historically, modelling withdrawal scenarios, or comparing portfolios on risk-adjusted return. Most income investors who use both tools use Portfolio Visualizer once a year to review allocation, and Income Refinery weekly to track income.
An honest note
When Income Refinery is not the right tool
If you're going to write a fair comparison, you have to be honest about where your own product doesn't fit. These are the cases where another tool will serve you better.
Cases where you should pick something else (and that's fine).
Income Refinery is built around a few opinionated choices: private-by-design, no account, manual or CSV-based data entry, one-time payment. Those choices are a feature for most income investors. For some, they're a deal-breaker, and the honest answer is to use a different tool.
- You need automated tax reports for capital gains. Income Refinery is an income tracker, not a tax engine. Sharesight is built for this.
- Your number-one requirement is automatic broker sync across many accounts. Income Refinery imports holdings via CSV/Excel and supports an 8-source dividend lookup pipeline, but it does not log into your brokerage. Sharesight, Snowball Analytics, TYD or Empower do.
- You want a native mobile app with push notifications for ex-dividend dates. DivTracker (iOS) and Stock Events (iOS/Android) are purpose-built for this.
- You're researching new dividend stocks and want a proprietary safety score. Simply Safe Dividends is the deeper research platform.
- You want to backtest a hypothetical allocation across 30+ years. Portfolio Visualizer is the standard for that and is partially free.
- You change devices and browsers constantly and won't reliably export a JSON backup. A cloud-based tracker will be less stressful for you. Income Refinery's privacy comes from local storage, which means you are the backup.
Frequently asked
Comparison FAQ
The most common questions about how Income Refinery stacks up against the alternatives.
See for yourself.
No signup. No risk.
The best way to compare any of these tools is to try them. Income Refinery's free version is genuinely useful, with no credit card, no email and no commitment. Pro adds the Dashboard, forecasts, What-If scenarios, Dividend Health and a record of your progress, for a one-time payment.
No account · No credit card · Your saved portfolio stays in your browser